The building block
-
firestoned
-
SpeedRacer
- Posts: 5030
- Joined: Wed Sep 19, 2007 9:14
- Location: Aurora
- Contact:
- roninsoldier83
- Posts: 664
- Joined: Wed Sep 24, 2008 9:14
- Location: Lakewood, CO
- Contact:
I've never really been a big fan of tubular SS manifolds, for a variety of reasons... but would recommend coating over wrapping. Exhaust manifolds on turbo cars see considerably higher EGT's than NA cars due to the additional exhaust back pressure from the turbine itself. Combine that with the fact that unlike NA cars, they also have to help support the additional weight of a turbo, putting more stress on them overall.
After several years of being around the DSM/EVO/WRX crowd, I've just heard of too many people wrapping tubular manifolds, and over the course of time ending up with cracked manifolds. It's kind of a win/lose situation. Wrapping can help with heat retention, which is an area where stainless steel is at a disadvantage when compared to cast iron. Heat retention will help with exhaust velocity, and ultimately the motor's overall VE.
It's fairly interesting stuff, especially to see on a dyno. Make several pulls with a cast iron manifold, getting it to full operating temperature (i.e. hot), watching spool-up on a graph. Then let cool for 10 minutes or so, make another pull, and you'll notice your spool will be a couple hundred RPM later, due to your exhaust manifold not being heated to the same degree. This effect is even more pronounced with stainless steel manifolds, they'll need a good bit of heat to maintain the same spool times.
I think tubular manifolds look badass, and typically have less obstruction than an OEM cast mani, but hate that they somewhat limit your options. When swapping over to larger than stock turbos, if I have my choice, I would rather run an external wastegate, for more precise boost control, and to eliminate excess exhaust turbulence (via external dump
), which depending on the turbo you're running, is usually good for anywhere from 10-40whp, allowing you to reduce your EGT's, and allowing you to make more power with less timing advance (read: safer). Not to mention they sound badass
Sure, with an OE manifold, you're likely going to have to toss it out to run an EWG as well (unless you are able to weld a flange to run a 38/44mm EWG onto your stock manifold, like some of the Honda guys do), but at least you're not throwing away money on a shiny tubular that will end up in the trash if you ever decide to run EWG. Just a personal opinion.
If available, what I would like to see would be an aftermarket cast manifold with an EWG port, like a few companies make for the old Neon SRT-4's:
http://www.cimotorsports.net/motor-sport-products/atp-exhaust-manifold-dodge-neon-srt4.html
^^^That would be AWESOME to see on a Mazdaspeed car!! Would help hold more boost to redline, might decrease spool time slightly, lower your EGT's, and scare the pants off of anything next to you once the WG opens (assuming you're dumping to atmosphere)! One day I'll get to hear an EWG on a Mazdaspeed car... one day. [/rant]
Until then, on a turbo manifold that helps support the turbo itself, I would go ceramic over wrap, mostly just for longevity purposes. Just my $.02 good luck!
After several years of being around the DSM/EVO/WRX crowd, I've just heard of too many people wrapping tubular manifolds, and over the course of time ending up with cracked manifolds. It's kind of a win/lose situation. Wrapping can help with heat retention, which is an area where stainless steel is at a disadvantage when compared to cast iron. Heat retention will help with exhaust velocity, and ultimately the motor's overall VE.
It's fairly interesting stuff, especially to see on a dyno. Make several pulls with a cast iron manifold, getting it to full operating temperature (i.e. hot), watching spool-up on a graph. Then let cool for 10 minutes or so, make another pull, and you'll notice your spool will be a couple hundred RPM later, due to your exhaust manifold not being heated to the same degree. This effect is even more pronounced with stainless steel manifolds, they'll need a good bit of heat to maintain the same spool times.
I think tubular manifolds look badass, and typically have less obstruction than an OEM cast mani, but hate that they somewhat limit your options. When swapping over to larger than stock turbos, if I have my choice, I would rather run an external wastegate, for more precise boost control, and to eliminate excess exhaust turbulence (via external dump
), which depending on the turbo you're running, is usually good for anywhere from 10-40whp, allowing you to reduce your EGT's, and allowing you to make more power with less timing advance (read: safer). Not to mention they sound badass
Sure, with an OE manifold, you're likely going to have to toss it out to run an EWG as well (unless you are able to weld a flange to run a 38/44mm EWG onto your stock manifold, like some of the Honda guys do), but at least you're not throwing away money on a shiny tubular that will end up in the trash if you ever decide to run EWG. Just a personal opinion.
If available, what I would like to see would be an aftermarket cast manifold with an EWG port, like a few companies make for the old Neon SRT-4's:
http://www.cimotorsports.net/motor-sport-products/atp-exhaust-manifold-dodge-neon-srt4.html
^^^That would be AWESOME to see on a Mazdaspeed car!! Would help hold more boost to redline, might decrease spool time slightly, lower your EGT's, and scare the pants off of anything next to you once the WG opens (assuming you're dumping to atmosphere)! One day I'll get to hear an EWG on a Mazdaspeed car... one day. [/rant]
Until then, on a turbo manifold that helps support the turbo itself, I would go ceramic over wrap, mostly just for longevity purposes. Just my $.02 good luck!
AKA- [color="Blue"]arctic_blue83[/color]
Mine: 2015 Subaru WRX
Hers: 2013 Subaru WRX
Mine: 2015 Subaru WRX
Hers: 2013 Subaru WRX
-
firestoned
- roninsoldier83
- Posts: 664
- Joined: Wed Sep 24, 2008 9:14
- Location: Lakewood, CO
- Contact:
firestoned wrote:thats a whole 'nother ball game there.... external WG is a big plus.. when the time comes, if needed I will switch out.. the cost is up there, expecially when you factor in the wastgate...
Yeah, it does get pricey, but completely worth it. You can typically find a good Tial 38mm for around $220-250 or so, with the larger Tial 44mm starting around $350+ or so. For anything under about a 44 lb/min turbo, a 38mm should suffice. If you don't mind a knockoff WG, they can be had for much cheaper. Assuming someone actually makes one to fit your application, a manifold with an EWG flange shouldn't be too much more than a standard non-flanged version, maybe $50 give or take, depending on the maker's profit margins. All that's necessary after that would be a dump pipe, which you can usually source/put together for less than $50. Completely worth it IMO. Well, assuming you don't want to plumb it back into the exhaust, as then it could get more pricey (not to mention you'll typically lose 10+whp or so vs dumping to atmosphere).
The only issue past that is making sure your IWG stays shut while driving... don't know about the K04, but for most Subaru used turbos, there are companies that make brackets to keep the IWG arm closed, for around $25 or so, making swapping easy, and no need to weld the IWG shut:
http://www.grimmspeed.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=60_33_36_38&products_id=131&osCsid=detrd5689crevhgpcgud6tl0g2
Most larger than stock turbos come with IWG's, so not really much of a "need" to swap out... you'll just be leaving a good amount of power on the table running an IWG vs EWG, but then again, the same can be said for every turbo, including the stock one
The amount of power left on the table just increases with the size of the turbo.AKA- [color="Blue"]arctic_blue83[/color]
Mine: 2015 Subaru WRX
Hers: 2013 Subaru WRX
Mine: 2015 Subaru WRX
Hers: 2013 Subaru WRX
- roninsoldier83
- Posts: 664
- Joined: Wed Sep 24, 2008 9:14
- Location: Lakewood, CO
- Contact:
EXACTLY!! It's funny, as I JUST found that less than a minute ago lol. That's perfect IMO. That manifold+Tial 38mm WG+dump pipe+closed IWG FTW!! I'm glad someone is bringing a manifold like that to the market for the Mazdaspeed cars

The perfect setup would be that, plus pick up a block off plate (typically less than $20), and an IWG bracket from a company like area1320, that way if you ever wanted to swap back to IWG for emissions ect, it would only take a few minutes. I'm pretty sure the area1320 guys will fab up an IWG bracket for just about turbo, might want to check them out:
http://area1320.com/products.html
AKA- [color="Blue"]arctic_blue83[/color]
Mine: 2015 Subaru WRX
Hers: 2013 Subaru WRX
Mine: 2015 Subaru WRX
Hers: 2013 Subaru WRX
-
firestoned
-
firestoned
- StormsOtherSide
- Posts: 112
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 9:14
- Location: Broomfield
- Contact:
Hey man, if you need a hand let me know! I will be more than willing to help. Firestone isnt too far for me 

MazdaSpeed3 GT
15% Tint, Blue Lamin'x Fogs, Vinyl EyeLids,
Cobb Short Ram Intake, HKS SSQV Black Edition BOV, Custom Deep Purple Flamed Intercooler, Corksport MM Inserts.
To Come: Wheels, Springs, COBB Short Throw Shifter, Tuner!
Favorite Quote: It's Not Real.
15% Tint, Blue Lamin'x Fogs, Vinyl EyeLids,
Cobb Short Ram Intake, HKS SSQV Black Edition BOV, Custom Deep Purple Flamed Intercooler, Corksport MM Inserts.
To Come: Wheels, Springs, COBB Short Throw Shifter, Tuner!

Favorite Quote: It's Not Real.
-
firestoned
thanks for the offers to help, everybody.. I will definitely let you know when I do the install..
Turbo Inlet Pipe is unexpectedly shipping early, as I got bumped WAY up on the list, so that a plus, shoul be here Wednesday. Also the turbo is ceramic coated already..another plus...
The manifold is at Premier Coatings right now getting coated, will be done Friday.
Cp-e intercooler will probably not arrive this next week, which sucks cause thats all Im waiting for now, besides the downpipe, which will be here Wednesday..
More pics of the parts and updates to come soon,,,
Turbo Inlet Pipe is unexpectedly shipping early, as I got bumped WAY up on the list, so that a plus, shoul be here Wednesday. Also the turbo is ceramic coated already..another plus...
The manifold is at Premier Coatings right now getting coated, will be done Friday.
Cp-e intercooler will probably not arrive this next week, which sucks cause thats all Im waiting for now, besides the downpipe, which will be here Wednesday..
More pics of the parts and updates to come soon,,,
-
tbot
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 41 guests



